AI Fail: Trying to Package Cursor Journal in Electron
Summary:
In this project, I aimed to package Cursor Journal, a NextJS 15 application using App Router, with Electron. The focus was on resolving various issues related to TypeScript errors, path issues, and build errors while ensuring the application runs as a desktop app. This process involved significant troubleshooting and discussions about the root causes of persistent errors. I was seriously frustrated with Claude’s inability to provide effective solutions at times, leading to a shift in strategy towards identifying the underlying problems instead of jumping straight to fixes.
I never got it working.
---
Details:
Dates: 2025-03-15 to 2025-03-17
1. Initial Setup and TypeScript Errors
The groundwork for the project involved packaging my Next.js application in Electron, which initially completed successfully after fixing numerous TypeScript errors. However, once I launched the Electron app, I encountered a blank screen, which pointed to potential path and permission issues. The conversations revolved around understanding the `next.config.ts` file and its implications on the build process.
2. Frustration with Build Failures
As I continued to troubleshoot, I faced a series of build errors related to missing modules and resources. I expressed frustration with the AI, particularly about its inability to predict the consequences of certain changes. This led to discussions about the importance of understanding the build process and the structure of the application, including the need to accurately manage paths for resources like `globals.css`.
3. Deep Dive into Error Logs
After rebuilding the app, I noticed that while the `electron-preload-debug.log` showed no errors, the app itself still had issues. This prompted a focus on identifying whether the errors were due to path-related problems or misconfigurations in the code, particularly in the preload and main scripts. I started questioning the logic behind proposed fixes, emphasizing a more structured approach to troubleshooting.
4. Shifts in Troubleshooting Strategy
Realizing that I was not making progress, I decided to change tactics and focus on identifying root causes rather than enforcing fixes. I asked the AI to help brainstorm hypotheses to test, especially around potential path issues caused by the packaging process. The discussions included examining logging outputs to trace where errors were occurring and determining the smallest changes that could lead to effective troubleshooting.
5. Exploring API and Static Exports
Another significant area of conversation involved the possibility of modifying the app's API usage to align better with Electron's handling of static exports. This included evaluating the risks and benefits of diverging from Next.js best practices. I asked the AI to research and suggest a way to integrate Express into the app, as there were indications that this approach had worked for others in similar situations.
6. Ongoing Challenges with TypeScript and ESlint
Throughout the discussions, I grappled with persistent TypeScript build errors that were affecting the overall functionality of the app. These errors led to a consideration of whether it was feasible to ignore certain linter rules to allow for a successful build, given that the application ran correctly despite the errors. The exploration of `eslint.config.mjs` highlighted the tension between maintaining clean code and ensuring functionality.
7. Reflecting on the Development Process
The conversations underscored a critical reflection on the development process, particularly the challenges of integrating Electron with a Next.js application. I expressed my frustrations clearly, emphasizing the need for step-by-step reasoning and thorough checks before implementing changes. This was crucial in the context of minimizing disruptions to the app's functionality during the packaging phase.
Ultimately, the journey through packaging my Next.js application in Electron was fraught with challenges, but it also provided valuable insights into the complexities of modern web development and the importance of careful troubleshooting and communication. In the end, this was a failure.
(written with Cursor Journal)